Saturday Night Live fans of a certain generation will remember “The Church Lady,” a character created by comedian Dana Carvey. The Church Lady entertained viewers with her only slightly hyperbolic judgmentalism and rife hypocrisy as she interviewed celebrity guests about their exploits. As the guests attempted to answer the Church Lady’s pointed questions, she would stare into the camera, smirk, and facetiously reply, “Well, isn’t that special.”

Eastern Shelby County voters are likely to feel similar cynicism and exude comparable sarcasm as they realize yet another election is in their near future and that the field of likely candidates is not all that, well, special.

State Senator Brent Taylor chose to seek re-election to the state senate and run for Congress in the newly gerrymandered Ninth Congressional District, which is egregiously allowed under state law. Taylor won both seats on November 3rd by extremely narrow margins but must resign one of them. Considering he loaned his congressional campaign $1.5 million, it is not necessary to think too long about which seat he plans to occupy and which he plans to vacate.

The state Constitution requires the Governor to set the date for a special election following the vacancy of a state senate seat if the date of the next state general election is more than a year away. State statute requires that the primary be held between 55 and 60 days after the writ of election is issued by the Governor. The general election must be held between 100 and 107 days from the date of the writ.

However, Senator Taylor has not resigned yet and has until January 3rd when he will be sworn in as a member of Congress. Governor-elect Marsha Blackburn does not take the oath of office until January 16th. Tennessee law does not prescribe a specific timeframe in which the Governor must issue the writ of election for a state legislative office. The timing and which Governor, the current or the recently elected, will call for the special election is unknown. What is certain is that there will be a special election in State Senate District 31, and the candidates are already jockeying for the honor.

In the general election, Democrat David Weatherspoon lost to Taylor by less than 3,000 votes with more than 73,000 cast. The heavily Republican district was considered to be unwinnable by many, and consequently the bulk of Weatherspoon’s funding arrived in the closing weeks of the campaign. The state Republican party pounded Weatherspoon with direct mail, accusing the St. Jude Children’s Hospital chaplain of being “extreme” based solely on a $50 contribution to a PAC supporting Medicare for all nine years ago. There was no reciprocal response from the state or national Democratic parties. But Weatherspoon, who never met a stranger, relentlessly knocked on doors across the district.

So, having worked so hard and having come so close to winning, Weatherspoon will be the Democratic Party’s candidate in the special election, right?

Wrong.

Within the coming days, Jerri Green, the Democratic nominee for Governor who lost in a close race to Republican Marsha Blackburn, is expected to announce she is running for State Senate District 31. Green believes that her name recognition and statewide fundraising ability better position her to defeat the Republican in this GOP-heavy district.

How conveeeenient!

Green is determined to be on the ballot and has shown no signs of backing down. Weatherspoon, realizing a “bloody” primary only helps the GOP, has chosen to step aside for the sake of his party and his community. Unfortunately, for the Democrats and Green, Republicans will keep the 31st district seat.

Green ran an impressive campaign despite being outspent more than 20 to 1 when you include Blackburn’s war chest, affiliated PACs, and outside groups. Green won big in Shelby and flipped several traditionally Republican counties. However, when faced with the raw facts, it is hard to conclude that Green can win the Senate race.

District 31 is a microcosm of the state of Tennessee. Brent Taylor won the district in 2022 by 33 points. Trump won the district in 2024 by 18 points. This time, in the face of an unsolicited sexting scandal, energized Democratic voters, and attacks from his Congressional opponent Justin Pearson and his allies, Taylor somehow managed to win.

Oh, I don’t know. Could it be…Satan!

There is something else.

Weatherspoon garnered 287 votes more than Green within the boundaries of district 31, though he began with virtually no name recognition and has never served in public office. In fact, Weatherspoon outpolled congressional candidates Justin Pearson and Heidi Kuhn in the majority of precincts shared by their districts and his. And unlike the race for Governor, there won’t be a David Hatley to siphon off nearly 10% of the Republicans’ vote.

On the Republican side, former City Councilman and commercial real estate broker Kemp Conrad has announced his candidacy. Conrad is a former Shelby County Republican Party Chair, who has made no secret of his intentions to run in a special election. Aside from cozying up with Taylor as of late and spouting a few GOP talking points, Conrad is generally considered much more mainstream than Taylor, and therefore more palatable to the business-minded independents and soft Republicans that populate much of the district. Conrad’s weaknesses include unabashed support for data centers and an appearance as a college student on the Jerry Springer Show, where he and his buddies claimed to have recorded sex acts with co-eds without their permission. The latter surfaced in 2007 when Conrad ran for the City Council. He claimed at the time that the appearance was a joke, and the stories were fabricated for TV. True or not, voters cared little about Senator Taylor’s unsolicited “dick pics,” so it is doubtful Conrad’s college exploits will have any effect.

One bright spot for the Democrats is that special elections notoriously have dismal turnout. This means money is less critical, though still necessary. What is essential is an effective “ground game.” Democrats were more successful at grassroots organization in the November cycle than Republicans and can give themselves a “fighting chance” if some of that can be replicated.

Oh, one other important nugget about the impending special election: it will cost taxpayers approximately $500,000 for voter turnout that won’t exceed 10%.

Well, isn’t that special.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Avatar

Lora Chilton5 days ago

Well said. Love the church lady references….exactly right for this ridiculous situation that could have been avoided and could have been resolved except for the extreme political game playing.